Optimistic Migrations and Unpredictable Outcomes

These two books about migrations within America and to America have given me a lot to think about. They go beneath the surface and find both heartwarming and unsettling consequences.

Image via Goodreads.com

The Warmth of Other Suns by Isabel Wilkerson

Between 1915 and 1970 six million Black Americans fled the South for cities in the North and West. Six million! This book masterfully brings together historical data, sociological analysis, interviews, poetry, song lyrics, and storytelling to create a compelling account of this migration.

The inside cover’s book description provides this overview: “Wilkerson interviewed more than a thousand people, and gained access to previously untapped data and official records, to write this definitive and vividly dramatic account of how these American journeys unfolded, altering our cities, our country, and ourselves.”

Wilkerson focuses on three particular individuals, their histories, journeys, tribulations, triumphs, struggles, and their evolving commitments to their choices. Through the stories of Ida Mae Gladney, George Starling, and Robert Foster, I understood and empathized with their difficult decisions, and was horrified by the circumstances that drove them away from the South. I was also very impressed by their hard work and determination in successfully creating new lives for themselves and their families.

Although this is a big book (543 pages) it is a thoroughly engaging read. Through it, I learned a lot about the day-to-day realities of slavery, the terrifying risks of escape, and the difficulties of re-establishing in a strange place. I was surprised by many of the things I learned, but particularly by the rigidity of the social class divisions both within and outside of the Black community. I had not realized how former slaves continued to be discriminated against after they had left slavery, but in less obvious ways that were difficult, and sometimes impossible, to address.

As the migrants moved (usually many times) they also had children, changed jobs, established new communities and, when it became possible, they revisited their hometowns. As these personal changes took place, so did social and political environments. America in 1970 had a very different character from the America of 1915. So different, in fact, that it feels as though the two historical periods could have been hundreds of years and not decades apart.

I thought I knew about slavery and its effects, but through this book I realized how little I really understood. I recommend it to anyone who wants a more nuanced understanding.

Image via Goodreads.com

The Sleepwalker’s Guide to Dancing by Mira Jacob

The Eapen family emigrated to America from India in the early 1980s, and this story tells that tale, but it is much, much more than a fictionalized biography. It is a wonderful exploration of character, culture, and echoes from the past.

Thomas Eapen, a neurosurgeon, his wife Kamala, an enthusiastic cook, and their gifted son Akhil arrive in Albuquerque with high hopes. Shortly after arriving they welcome their daughter, Amina, into the world and together they navigate all the expected and unexpected difficulties of adjustment to a different way of life.

We learn their story through the eyes of thirty-year-old Amina who works as a professional photographer in Seattle. She reflects on a family trip back to Salem, in India, when she was a small child and how they left her grandmother’s home earlier than planned. She also recalls the difficulties she and her brother experienced in being social outcasts in their American schools.

Amina’s professional life takes a dramatic turn when she takes a picture that traumatizes her. It is of an Indigenous American activist who deliberately plunges off a bridge, and the fame it brings her causes an unbearable personal conflict.

We also learn that her brother died in a car crash as a young man and then, later, her father begins behaving strangely and she is urged to come home. As she tries to help her father and reassure her mother, Amina provides for the reader a thoughtful bridge between the past and the present, the old country and the new.

This is more than just a slice of immigrant life. It is an engaging study of complex and endearing characters, of familial ties that are stronger than the family members might wish, and messy relationships that endure hardships regardless of all the dysfunctions.

I don’t know why Mira Jacob chose the book’s title, but it may have to do with the ways in which we sometimes sleepwalk through life and all its vicissitudes. The dance, in this context, may be the ways we accommodate the changes in those closest to us. I’m just guessing, but this book describes all those things beautifully. It also describes some delicious food! There is a lot to like in this tender reflection on some uncomfortable realities.


  1. I just recently read Wilkerson’s recent book, Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents. In it she argues that the US has a caste system and compares it to India and Nazi Germany, but it is mostly about the US. It was a real eye-opener to me about the black experience in America. I would recommend it. I had been thinking about reading her first book- now after reading your review I will certainly get a copy.

    By the way there was quite a bit of interesting discussion on CNN last night after Biden’s press conference. One woman (sorry I didn’t get her name) has written a book about why civil wars start. She points out it occurs when a country is divided along ethnic, religious and racial lines. Would like to read her book as well. I had previously thought the idea of a civil war in the US was ridiculous, but maybe not so.

  2. I got the book “The Warmth of Other Suns” last year but I felt I didn’t have the time to give it and I wanted to be sure to absorb as much as I could. It’s now on my list for this year. I’m looking forward to it. I also got a book about Ruth Bader Ginsburg last year shortly after her death. It also awaits my reading. 2022 seems to be my year of reading lengthy books on subjects I know so little about. Thank you for giving me more reasons to start! I already read “State of Terror” by Louise Penny and Hillary Rodham Clinton. And have 2 more I am now reading, “Hamnet” and “All She Carried” (I hope I have that title correct). Please do keep up the reviews. I so look forward to them.

  3. I too enjoy your book reviews. I hadn’t heard of either of these books and look forward to reading them. btw, I read and enjoyed “Oive, Again”. Thanks for that review as well!

  4. Think about downloading recorded books from the library… than you don’t have to go on those icy streets to return!! I listened to Caste! Great, eye opening book!!

Please leave a comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.