Living and Learning

Slacktivism, Activism, and Pipe Dreams

Rally Against Dakota Access Pipeline

Rally Against Dakota Access Pipeline. Source: Fibonacci Blue (CC BY 2.0)

Yes, I am a slacktivist. I am one of the million or more people who checked into Facebook as though I were in Standing Rock, North Dakota, to symbolically support the demonstrators there.  The Sioux people and their allies are protesting against the installation of a pipeline that skirts around two native reservations and is intended to cross an essential waterway.

They don’t want traditional hunting and grazing lands disturbed, and they really don’t want possible ancestral burial grounds dug up. They are also very suspicious of the safety of these pipelines with regard to land and water resources.

As an Albertan, I have very mixed feelings about pipelines.  The oil and gas industries are primary contributors to the Albertan economy and most of us are directly or indirectly indebted to these industries for employment. We also benefit every day from the use of oil and gas, and would not like to imagine our lives without those sources of energy.

At the same time, the industry in general has failed to adequately monitor and maintain millions of miles of pipelines, some of which are now fifty years old.  They may be underground or above ground, on prairies or through mountains, near water sources or near natural habitats.

Leaks or accidental ruptures may be large or small, and may be discovered quickly or not for a very long time. But, whenever there has been a pipeline leak, the industries have done their best to clean up as quickly and efficiently as possible. Pipelines are, we are told, safer methods of transportation for oil and gas than are trucks and trains, which are more likely to crash and cause fires.

As it stands, then, our choices seem to be all bad.  We can either risk fires or polluted ground and water, or we can give up using oil and gas. However, we can’t give them up until we have adequately created alternatively sources of energy, and that’s going to take some time.

There is, though, another possibility that I don’t see being discussed much (or at all) in the media.  The companies that distribute oil and gas could put a lot more time, money, and effort into upgrading existing pipelines and inventing safer new ones. In fact, those requirements should be legislated into the permits to build pipelines.

Since we know that old pipelines become less stable, and since we know that even newer pipelines sometimes leak, then more of the industries’ efforts should go into maintenance, research, and development. We need reassurance that before any new pipelines are installed, the old ones are being consistently and effectively maintained. Then we need to know that new pipeline technology does a better job of preserving the land and water sources than does the old technology.

It’s not good enough to spend a lot of money on clean-ups.  We want to reduce spills and leaks to zero. But that is, literally, a pipe dream.

 

7 replies »

  1. Damned if you do and damned if you don’t.
    While alternative energy is still very much a pipe dream (sic) and so much investment is tied up in fossil fuels and governments are prepared to go to war just to secure a better deal for oil it is going to take a huge dangling carrot before those involved turn away from the oil industry.

    I wish I even had an inkling of an idea how to tackle this problem, as I am sure most people do.

      • Vested interested is always a difficult thing to deal with and more so in a country like the US that tends to be somewhat insular in its outlook.

        When someone can see their way clear to making a lot of money and avoid being trampled by the oil industry for example, then we will quickly see fossil fuels replaced.
        Hydrogen is already available at certain Gas Stations in California as an alternative to petrol and Toyota ( I think) have at least one car that utilizes it.
        How long would it take to develop this to its full potential?
        I have no idea, but it can’t be that much more difficult that drilling for oil, surely?

      • Have you ever watched the movie Other People’s Money, with Danny de Vito and Gregory Peck?
        Not a new movie.
        It is poignent but also very funny and very relevant. If you haven’t seen it I highly recommend it.
        You will understand why when you see it.

Please leave a comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s