Living and Learning

The Moral Dilemma In Being Smart

http://decider.com/2015/07/23/an-honest-liar-must-see-documentary-netflix/Specialists and experts of various kinds are able to do illegal or immoral or antisocial things simply because the rest of us don’t really understand what they do. Even worse than that; we want to believe what they tell us.

In the documentary An Honest Liar, the illusionist James Randi explains the difference between magicians who entertain us and charlatans who defraud us.  In both situations the audiences are willing to be deceived, but the motivations of the deceivers are different. Randi cautions us to be careful about what we want to believe and not to ignore our hunches when we think something is wrong.

In my newsfeed today were articles about the “rogue coders” who fitted software that would cheat emissions tests into Volkswagen vehicles; shell companies that steal the deeds to people’s homes; the systemic ethical problems in Wall Street; the cover-up of global warming research at Exxon; and concerns about the content of the Trans Pacific Partnership agreement.

What all of these news stories have in common is that they all involve expert knowledge and research being used to benefit the few at the expense of the many.  I’ve long ago accepted that I’m being fleeced by big corporations, but somehow I always assumed that experts, researchers, and scientists were morally neutral in all this. I don’t think so any more because they clearly are not working on my behalf.

When you are the only person in the room who really knows what you are talking about, it must be easy to convince people that what you are doing is right and good. Problems arise, though, when what you think is good turns out to be bad for a lot of people. Just because I don’t know what is involved in computer coding, or real estate law, or high finance etc., does not mean those who do should be able to easily abuse my trust in them.

It is possible for experts to cheat us mostly because they work for industries that believe the highest good is making money. I don’t know how we can change that so they value people or the planet more, but I do know that we have to try.  Experts, scientists, and researchers should have a means to test not just their research methods, but also their ethics.

Christine Lagarde, managing director of the International Monetary Fund said, “[So] if the financial industry is to put people before profits, and society before shareholders, we need to see a change in the values and behavior of individuals themselves. We need a culture that holds individuals accountable for the consequences of their behavior—good and bad.” That is an idea whose time has come not just for the financial industry, but for all industries. Oh, and politicians, too.

So much of our lives involves systems and technologies that we don’t understand, it’s easiest to simply trust the people who do understand them. We must watch out for that. We may not be able to become experts in these things, but we can take a closer look at the people who ask us to trust them.

4 replies »

  1. I agree and don’t get me started on disease care, aka “health” care. There is way too much money in keeping us all sick. I believe the sad part is, that if everyone would put ethics and people first, they’d make even more money and there would be plenty for all. Health Wealth and Happiness. But fear of loss is more powerful…for instance think how many billions of dollars and jobs would be lost if they found a cure for cancer….especially if it’s something cheap, like high doses of vitamin C or something….drug companies, lobbyist, pharmacists, researchers, treatment centers, doctors, non-profits, and on and on…having said that, I’m still a believer that if they DID find a cure and were brave enough to risk the billions lost, all those people would find something even better to do, and all that money would still be generated but for something better and more creative.

    • When I spent several years being Geoff’s advocate in the health care maze, I vacillated between being profoundly grateful for the good care he got and frustrated with the difficulty in getting enough information to make informed decisions.

      Most of the people in the health care system, especially those on the front lines, are good people doing their best. The problems you refer to are, I suspect, at much higher levels where decisions are made behind closed doors.

Please leave a comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s